School Counselors Say Their Burden is Growing
A successful boys varsity basketball coach at Mukwonago High School, Christiansen
increasingly had difficulty focusing on hoops as he fretted about the troubled
students he counseled. It’s hard to concentrate on the “big rival on Friday
night when you’ve been dealing with a suicidal girl for four hours,” he said.
So a year ago, he stepped down as head coach — with a 63-30 record over four
seasons — to devote himself to counseling kids at the Waukesha County high
school.
Like Christiansen, guidance counselors throughout the state are feeling the
rigors of jobs they say are increasingly demanding as society and its problems
grow more complex.
“They are getting stretched thin because there are many more demands on
counselors’ time and expertise,” said Robert “Pete” Havens, a professor in the
department of counselor education at the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh and
coordinator of its school counseling program.
When people ask Mark Kuranz about his job, the lead guidance counselor for the
Racine Unified School District and a counselor at Case High School tells them:
“I have an appointment book just like a doctor and it’s filled up. But I’m
also working an ER and handle every crisis that comes up.”
Years ago, counselors spent their time advising students about class schedules
and colleges while occasionally helping kids experiencing rocky times at home.
Today, while still handling those traditional tasks, they juggle many more
duties, including: Violence prevention, sparked in part by a wave of deadly
school shootings across the nation and more students bringing weapons to
schools.
Grief counseling, to help students, teachers and others cope with tragic
losses, such as the death of a student in a traffic accident.
Career planning, in which counselors spend more time preparing students for
specific jobs after college or technical school and, in some cases, right
after high school graduation.
Community outreach, working with social service agencies to set up
educational, recreationaland counseling programs for children after school.
Case High School works with the Bray Center, where kids go after school for
recreation,tutoring, career planning and anger management workshops.
“We’re doing a lot more connecting with communities,” Kuranz said. “That
wasn’t happening 10 years ago.” Betty Miller, a guidance counselor at Waukesha
West High School, said: “The job has certainly changed since I became a
counselor in 1976. Then, we had the luxury of meeting with a student once a
week for several weeks. We don’t have that luxury now.”
Miller, who is responsible for about 375 students, has found herself in recent
years at funeral homes to “help kids through crises” or coached them on
“funeral etiquette.”
“I never thought I would be doing that,” Miller said.
It’s all part of the complex role of guidance counselors today, said Michael
Thompson, the director student services/prevention and wellness for the state
Department of Public Instruction.”The specific role of the school counselor is
not very well understood,” he said. “So they are pulled in many different
directions. . . . They do get stretched thin.”
Counselors say they are feeling more harried at a time when students could use
more individual attention. “As counselors, we went into the profession to help
kids be successful and help get them through tough times,” Christiansen said.
“We do some of that, but that’s becoming a smaller and smaller piece of the
job.”
In Milwaukee Public Schools, as in other districts, guidance counselors are
spending more time on educational and career planning “to make sure kids are
prepared for work and college,” said Lynn Krebs, the district’s coordinator of
guidance and career education.
They are targeting their efforts in those areas because 75% of the district’s
students are from homes with low to moderate incomes and many have “no college
role models and increasingly no high school role models,” Krebs said. Those
students need to hear from counselors about the importance of maintaining good grades
and how the choices they make will affect their chances of getting into
college or landing a job,Krebs said. Additionally, MPS counselors increasingly
spend time trying to secure college and technical school scholarships for
students, so they can have the same educational choices as their peers in
other districts, Krebs said.
All of these added duties come at a time of tight
budgets, when districts have little financial leeway to hire more counselors.
While the DPI recommends a 250-to-1 student-counselor ratio in grades 7 to 12
and 400-to-1 in grades K-6, many high school counselors handle 300 or more
students. In MPS, the ratio is 425 to 1 at the high school level and 500 to 1
at the middle school level. “We were making progress in getting more
counselors, but what with budget cuts and things . .. my sense is the ratio
has begun getting larger,” said Havens, the UW-Oshkosh professor.
Racine’s Kuranz handles about 325 students and some of the duties formerly
held by the district’s counselor coordinator, a position that was cut about
four years ago.
“If I could have a much smaller ratio, I could touch more kids’ lives,” he
said. “There simply isn’t enough time to get to know them all.”
At Homestead High School in the Mequon-Thiensville district, administrators
this year had hoped to add another guidance counselor. But the new position
was trimmed as part of$400,000 in budget cuts. The five counselors at the
Ozaukee County school handle about 1,400 students. “We’re sitting here
swamped writing letters of recommendations (to colleges). With 94% of our
seniors going to college, we spend almost all of our time writing letters of
recommendation and processing applications through December,” said Lin Lesar,
the co-director of guidance at Homestead. The Homestead counselors also run
college workshops for parents, hold college conferences with each student and
his or her parents, and schedule and conduct college entrance exams and
National Merit Scholarship tests. “I think every day we feel stretched thin,”
Lesar said.
“I’d like to spend more time with the students, especially freshmen and
sophomores. What happens now is you put so much focus on the seniors and their
applications. But you can’t be in two places at once.”
Journal Sentinel Online